Cheryl Strayed hiked a long section of the PCT in 1995. The boots she wore then probably looked something like the stock image on the cover of her book. Very...sturdy. And from the descriptions therein, it's clear that she had a horrific time with her feet. By which I don't mean to say that her feet hurt, or that she got blisters, though both of those things are true--but she was losing toenails. Wait, let me be perfectly accurate: she was tearing out her own toenails because it made her feet HURT LESS. The very idea makes me queasy.
I enjoyed reading this book, but a few pieces of the paradigm have changed significantly since '95, like footwear. I've already said to Dad, please, don't run away with the idea that ripping out toenails is par for the course on a long-distance hike; that it's normal. It isn't.
Boots are designed to protect your feet, yes?--from rain, snow, rocks, burrs and things that go bump in the night--and as consumers we buy right into the notion that our feet need to be protected from our exciting lives. Sometimes they do! If you're exploring pressure-ridges in Antarctica at forty below, for instance, you want some boots. My standard-issue extreme-cold-weather bunny boots had no treads on the bottom and consisted of less than 50% foot. Wearing them, I couldn't walk very well--I'd just sort of bounce along and hope I wouldn't encounter any stairs--but my feet were never cold, not ever--and as far as the US Antarctic Program was concerned, that was the most important feature. All such protective boots serve a very specific purpose, and that purpose is not travel.
But if you're planning to spend five whole months walking, you had better lend a little more thought to the question of what you're trying to protect your feet from. Is it snakes? No. Spilled coffee? Nope. Subzero temperatures? Nooo... Is it the person attached, battering them unrelentingly against the ground for MILE after everlasting MILE? You're getting warmer!
Emma "Grandma" Gatewood thru-hiked the Appalachian Trail in 1955, solo, at age 67, wearing Keds sneakers. She's a famous lady in the realm of ultralight hikers nowadays; at the time she was more of an eccentric novelty (maybe because she was also pitching a tarp made out of a shower curtain). Ray Jardine still had a difficult row to hoe in the early 90s, trying to convince people of the superiority of lightweight footwear. It sounds like the point has carried by a few thousand demonstrations, however, because it's lesson number one these days for somebody like myself, just starting to learn about the PCT. A thru-hike isn't an extended camping trip so much as a very long walk. The best shoes for a very long walk are walking shoes. Boots ain't made for walking.
Most hikers these days choose a well-treaded trail runner, or sneakers. Just go to the store and try on as many pairs of shoes as you can stand before you want to start throwing them at the unhelpful sales associates. The shoes don't have to be fancy, or expensive--because you're going to destroy them, and all of their successors. They ought to be comfortable, light-colored, lightweight, breathable, and a little too big. After marching a few days in the blazing-hot desert, feet swell and rub against the inside of a fitted shoe. And they sweat--a lot. The result of this combination of moisture and abrasion is blisters, so you choose your shoes with an eye to heading off the problem from the beginning. Let them breathe, and don't worry about "waterproof." It's summertime! GoreTex or heavy leather boots can't keep your feet dry when the moisture is coming from the inside; nor will they prove very effective while fording a knee-deep stream. They'll just never dry out afterwards.
With decent footwear and a little attention to rinsing out [non-cotton] socks, most people will suffer a couple of blisters, no more, in the first two or three weeks of hiking, and that's it. THAT'S IT. Your feet adapt and toughen, and it's no longer an issue. I am not making this up.
Without the high boot tops to keep debris at bay, some people choose to wear gaiters over their shoes. In a high snow year, a little more traction may be desirable through the Sierras, and microspikes adequately serve that purpose. The shoe stays the same, though.
The principal drawback to sneakers or trail runners is their lack of durability, so yes, you have to replace them at regular intervals--how often depends on the shoe. You'll know when they're done, because you'll feel it in your shins, knees, hips, and back. (Talk to a devoted runner, they can tell you all about it.) But the great thing about sneakers is you can buy a new pair in virtually any settlement in this country, or online for delivery to the next trail town.
Emma "Grandma" Gatewood thru-hiked the Appalachian Trail in 1955, solo, at age 67, wearing Keds sneakers. She's a famous lady in the realm of ultralight hikers nowadays; at the time she was more of an eccentric novelty (maybe because she was also pitching a tarp made out of a shower curtain). Ray Jardine still had a difficult row to hoe in the early 90s, trying to convince people of the superiority of lightweight footwear. It sounds like the point has carried by a few thousand demonstrations, however, because it's lesson number one these days for somebody like myself, just starting to learn about the PCT. A thru-hike isn't an extended camping trip so much as a very long walk. The best shoes for a very long walk are walking shoes. Boots ain't made for walking.
![]() |
one popular model |
With decent footwear and a little attention to rinsing out [non-cotton] socks, most people will suffer a couple of blisters, no more, in the first two or three weeks of hiking, and that's it. THAT'S IT. Your feet adapt and toughen, and it's no longer an issue. I am not making this up.
Without the high boot tops to keep debris at bay, some people choose to wear gaiters over their shoes. In a high snow year, a little more traction may be desirable through the Sierras, and microspikes adequately serve that purpose. The shoe stays the same, though.
The principal drawback to sneakers or trail runners is their lack of durability, so yes, you have to replace them at regular intervals--how often depends on the shoe. You'll know when they're done, because you'll feel it in your shins, knees, hips, and back. (Talk to a devoted runner, they can tell you all about it.) But the great thing about sneakers is you can buy a new pair in virtually any settlement in this country, or online for delivery to the next trail town.